Camshaft Wear – Causes, Symptoms, and Solutions

Key Takeaways

• A worn camshaft can sap power and, if ignored, lead to serious engine damage.
• Almost every camshaft problem stems from lubrication issues – wrong oil, dirty oil, or too little oil.
• Common warning signs include a persistent ticking sound, loss of throttle response, rough idling, and warning lights.
• When you inspect the camshaft, look for pitting, scoring, or metal smearing – each pattern tells a story about what went wrong.
• The only dependable fix is replacing the camshaft with a full kit (new camshaft plus lifters – and ideally a fresh timing chain or belt).
• Prevent trouble by sticking to the manufacturer’s oil-change schedule with the right grade of high-quality oil.
  

---

What the Camshaft Does (And Why It Matters)

Deep in your engine, the camshaft times the opening and closing of intake and exhaust valves. Its lobes are precision-machined and rely on a thin film of oil to slide smoothly under immense pressure. Even a tiny scratch or wear spot can knock horsepower off the table; a major failure can destroy pistons, bearings, or worse.

Spotting a Bad Camshaft

1. Ticking or Tapping Noises. You’ll hear a regular, rhythmic tick from the top of the engine – clear evidence that a cam lobe has worn down and the valve clearance is too large.
2. Power Loss & Hesitation. Worn lobes choke off airflow. You’ll feel it as sluggish acceleration, poor throttle response, or a rough idle.
3. Check Engine Light. Codes like P0340 (camshaft position circuit) or P0011 (timing over-advanced) often show up when the cam sensor can’t keep up with the damaged cam profile.
4. Metal Shavings in the Oil. Finding metal flakes in your oil or filter is a red alert – your camshaft (and possibly other parts) is shedding metal.

Why Cam Lobes Wear Out

Almost every time you see a ruined camshaft, it traces back to lubrication failures:

• Oil Starvation: Low oil level or blocked oil passages can leave the lobes running dry.
• Contaminated Oil: Coolant leaks, fuel dilution, or dirt turns oil into a grinding slurry that scratches the metal.
• Wrong Oil Viscosity: Using oil that’s too thin or thick – or oil that’s lost its anti-wear additives – robs the camshaft of its protective film.
• Improper Break-In: Flat-tappet cams demand a special 20-30 minute run-in procedure; skip it, and the fresh lobes never “mate” properly with the lifters.
• Reusing Old Lifters: When you fit a new cam to worn lifters, the uneven lifter surface chews up the new lobes almost instantly.

Reading the Damage: Wear Patterns Explained

• Pitting & Spalling: Tiny craters or chips indicate surface fatigue, often from corrosion during idle periods.

• Scoring & Gouging: Fine scratches or deep grooves point to hard particles – or sludge – circulating in the oil.

• Galling: Shiny, torn metal means the oil film completely failed, causing the lobes and lifters to cold-weld and rip apart.

• Discoloration: Blue or purple hues reveal that extreme friction overheated the metal.

Fixing It (And Stopping It from Happening Again)

Once the camshaft is damaged, the only reliable route is replacement. Always install a full kit:

• New Camshaft + Lifters: They must be a matched set.
• Timing Chain/Belt & Tensioners: Fresh components here prevent another failure down the road.

Prevention Is Priceless

• Stick to the oil-change intervals with the grade your engine maker specifies – don’t skimp.
• Use top-quality oil and filters.
• Keep your oil level topped up, and don’t ignore a low-oil warning.
• Give the engine a moment to warm up before pushing it hard.
• Avoid long idles that let oil cool and condense moisture or acids.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Can I keep driving on a bad camshaft?
No – driving on a worn cam lobe sends metal particles through the engine, risking damage to bearings, pistons, and more. You could end up replacing the entire engine.

Q2: Why must lifters be replaced with the camshaft?
Cam lobes and lifters wear together over time, matching each other’s surface imperfections. New cam lobes against old lifters guarantee the lobes will be scored and fail quickly.

Q3: Is a ticking noise always the camshaft?
Not always. Ticks can come from a faulty hydraulic lifter or simply valves that need adjustment. A proper diagnosis pinpoints the real source.

Q4: How long should a camshaft last?
With regular oil changes and proper care, a camshaft is designed to last the life of the engine – often exceeding 150,000 miles. Neglect cuts that lifespan dramatically.